Reading: Understanding Text Structure, Cohesion & Coherence (Mastery): C1 Lesson 4: Critically Evaluating Author's Purpose, Stance, and Underlying Ideology

Critical Reading Mastery

C1 Lesson 4: Evaluating Purpose, Stance & Ideology

Goal: Go beyond "what" the text says to understand "why" it was written, the author's attitude (stance), and their underlying worldview (ideology).

1. Critical Terminology

Stance
Stance ជំហរ (Author's attitude/opinion)
Ideology
Ideology មនោគមវិជ្ជា (Belief system/worldview)
Bias
Bias លំអៀង (Prejudice)
Implicit
Implicit ដោយមិនចំហ (Implied, not stated)

2. The Iceberg Model of Text

In advanced reading, the explicit text is just the tip. The real meaning lies beneath.

Explicit Text
(Words, Grammar, Facts)
Water Line (Inference Required)
Purpose (Why?) Stance (Attitude) Ideology (Worldview)

3. Analyzing with a Lens

Read the short text below. We can analyze it to find the author's hidden ideology regarding urban development.

Lens: Pro-Development vs. Conservation
"The city's skyline is finally maturing into a modern metropolis. While some cling to the past, trying to preserve inefficient low-rise structures, forward-thinking planners understand that vertical growth is the only sustainable path."
Analysis: Uses positive words ("maturing", "modern") for development and negative/dismissive words ("cling to the past", "inefficient") for preservation.

Author's Ideology: Progress is defined by modernization and efficiency; tradition is an obstacle.

4. Critical Evaluation Check

Text: "The government's handout program encourages dependency rather than empowering citizens to work."

1. What is the author's likely ideological stance?

Text: "These 'protesters' disrupted the morning commute, causing chaos for hardworking citizens."

2. How does the author frame the protesters? (Stance)
3. What does "Implicit Ideology" mean?

Post a Comment

Hi, please Do not Spam in Comment